Comparison of book iliad and the film troy achilles iliad scribd. Achilles is the son of peleus and the seanymph thetis. On the other hand, there are significant differences between the movie and the epic. Some pieces of materials will be quoted to support my understanding that in the iliad of homer, briseis is more than an object in achilless eyes. Essay on comparison of troy and the iliad 883 words bartleby. Dicuss similarities and differences between homers iliad and the movie troy essay sample.
When it comes to epic poetry, the iliad and the odyssey are the two names that spring to mind. In this lesson, well discuss the differences and similarities between homers the iliad and wolfgang petersens 2004 film troy. Viewers should note the difference between faithful adaptations and. Robert fitzgerald university press 1974 has been retold in many other forms, the most recent being the blockbuster film troy 2004, wolfgang peterson. Hector was married to andromache, he had an infant son. Here are some differences between the movie and the poem. The differences between the movie troy and the poem iliad and the explanation of why they occurred. In the movie troy the gods played no role in events that took place. Quora user i disagree with you about the second point of view you put forward. In homers iliad, the gods played a major part in the trojan war. However there are several major differences between them, as troy. There are many differences between homers iliad and the 2004 movie troy, starring brad pitt as achilles. Ive got a paper to write do i do anything but write papers.
Comparison of book iliad and the film troy free download as word doc. This work is generally credited to the ancient greek poet named homer. Paris takes helen from her home only after she is promised to him by aphrodite which was a separate story not directly told in the iliad. The differences consisting of hector running away from achilles in the iliad and a long and glorious battle between them both in the movie troy. Troy, based on the iliad, has proven to be a very loose adaptation of homers classic and one cannot help noticing the major differences between the book and the movie.
On the whole, troy makes a number of changes to the iliad, mainly as a result of the filmmakers wanting to appeal to a modern audience. Discuss similarities and differences between homers iliad and wolfgang petersons film troy with reference to what it has added to modern day society. A major difference in the film was that there were no intervening or actions of the gods whatsoever, whereas in th. The iliad v troy comparsions between the modern film. Smellin of troy what follows is a partial list of discrepancies between troy the bigbudget hollywood movie and troy the epic poem and archeological history. Meneleuss death, pariss escape, helens situation, and the trojan princesses. Get an answer for what are the differences between the movie troy and the iiliad. In the movie troy, briseis is a member of priams family which she actually wasnt. Similarities and differences between troy and the iliad. The three major upsetting differences in troy compared to the iliad are the absence of the gods, the weak character and plot development, and the addition, exclusion, and reversal of key points. Centred on the trojan war, these two ancient greek epic poems are world renowned not only for the engaging dialogue with which they present turn of events but also for the beauty with which it is unfolded. It is very apparent that the film troy, directed by wolfgang peterson, has been.
Between the book and the film there are a wealth of differences, and similarities only lie in the basic, undisputed ideas. From babylon to america, the prophecy movie by school for prophets attila kakarott duration. What are the differences between odysseus in the iliad and. In this blog im going to show the differences of the battle between the great fighters. Divine intervention was a major variable in homers iliad. Book and film comparison the iliad became adapted into a film during 2004 called troy, in which the story was both dramatically and subtly changed in its adaptation. Sep 15, 20 from babylon to america, the prophecy movie by school for prophets attila kakarott duration. Achilles in troy vs the iliad general discussion non. Apr 14, 20 the fight between hector and achilles is told in different ways with the iliad and troy.
Your browser does not currently recognize any of the video formats available. The film also omits a lot of characters and subplots from the iliad. Essay on comparison of troy and the iliad 883 words. Get your custom essay on differences between troy movie and the iliad.
Agamemnon is inspired to attack troy by a dream sent by the gods, who want to bring his army misery for taking briseis away from achilles. Major differences between the homers iliad and the film troy. The iliad v troy comparsions between the modern film troy. Both the film and the poem have the same ending plots, such as the blockade of troy by the greeks, the. The fight between hector and achilles is told in different ways with the iliad and troy. The movie script took many liberties with the poem and the characters. The ancient legend of troy, recorded in homers epic poem the iliad oxford trans. The movie troy written by david benioff and directed by wolfgang petersen was inspired by the iliad, an ancient greek poem about the time of warrior achilles argument with king agamemnon during the trojan war. The similarities between achilles and hector is that both lived in the present moment and both wanted to achieve glory in order to be the hero that their homeland needed, while the differences include achilles being stubborn and angry while hector was prideful, yet cowardly and impulsive. A comparison of the differences between the book iliad and. Briseis is a trojan priestess and hectors cousin, captured during the attack on apollos temple. Homers iliad does not fail to portray the role of the gods in the trojan war and it also includes several magical elements within the poem. Hektor in the iliad, homer portrays the trojan war and the siege of troy. Differences between troy movie and iliad free essays.
Oct 19, 2012 one of the major differences between the two texts is the role of the greek gods. A comparsion between the epic poem the iliad and the modern film troy the film troy is a movie released in 2004 and was directed by wolfgang petersen, and has been influenced by the classical epic poem, the iliad which has been credited of the greek poet homer. Achilles commands the myrmidons, soldiers from his homeland of phthia in greece, his wrath at agamemnon for taking his war prize, briseis, turns into the the main subject in the iliad. A ancient greek vase depicting ajax preparing to commit suicide the reason for these differences between the iliad and the film troy are nearly 100% economic as when looking at each individual example of the differences all of them are. There are many similarities that can be found between the iliad and the movie troy due to the fact the movie is based off the iliad. Although homer is said to have written the epic in 725 bce and the fall of troy supposedly have happened almost 400 years before the epic was written, but people do take homers word and hold them as truths. Differences between troy and the iliad 1402 words cram. Both texts deal with the same subject, the siege of troy which was ended with the trickery of the wooden horse. This was a major plot point in homers iliad, as the gods who fought on the battlefield had somewhat of an influence on the outcome of each battle and eventually the outcome of the war. How does the film about troy in greek mythology differ from. Dicuss similarities and differences between homers iliad and. Jul 24, 2017 between the book and the movie there are a wealth of differences. One of the major differences between the two texts is the role of the greek gods. And homer would have loved the combat scenes though the iliad itself is a.
Book and film comparison the iliad became adapted into a film during 2004 called troy, in which the story was both dramatically and subtly changed. Differences between the iliad and the movie troy 854 words. Nov 27, 2017 homers iliad, the earliest greek poem, narrates the archetypal war between europeans and asiatics divided by the hellespont. The iliad begins in the 9th twelvemonth of the 10 twelvemonth besieging of the greeks upon troy. The film troy which is directed by wolfgang peterson has been deeply influenced by the epic poem, the iliad. Stories about oedipus, hercules, and the titans have been told throughout the years captivating generation after generation. The movie s closing titles state that the film was inspired by the iliad of homer, but the end of the film is based loosely on book 2 of the aeneid of virgil. Comparison of the movie troy and the iliad june 10, 2012 posted by essaywriter in free essays the historical events depicted in homers iliad was traditionally a subject of scientific and literature discussions and the definite answer concerning the extent to which the events depicted by the ancient artist are truthful is still. First and most disappointing, was the absence of the gods in the movie troy. Similarities and differences between the iliad and the movie troy 1057 words 5 pages. The iliad begins in the ninth year of the ten year siege of the greeks upon troy, whereas the movie shows paris taking helen away from troy angering menelaus in the process. New haven sda temple brooklyn, ny recommended for you 2. It is very apparent that the film troy, directed by wolfgang peterson, has been heavily influenced by the epic poem, the iliad, a work commonly credited to the ancient greek poet homer.
The iliad verses troy i n the movie its stated that agamemnon brought the kings together for this war, which really isnt true. A ancient greek vase depicting ajax preparing to commit suicide the reason for these differences between the iliad and the film troy are nearly 100% economic as when looking at each individual example of the differences all of them are either due to lowering expensescomplexity of making the film troy i. Homers iliad via the movie troy 2004 professor edith hall. The major similarities between the two would to me be, that achilles was a trojan. What are the differences between the movie troy and. Dicuss similarities and differences between homers iliad. A comparison of the differences between the book iliad and the.
The iliad tells only a small portion of the 10 year trojan warabout 9 weeks, i believe. Some major differences between homers iliad and wolfgang petersens film troy, is that there was no mention of the gods being participants in the battle of troy. Throughout the lesson, well talk about the similarities and differences between. Troy is a movie that first debuted in 2004 that was based on the epic, the iliad. The iliad vs troy for years, greek literature has transitioned from ancient scrolls, to school textbooks, and often times to the big screen. Between the book and the movie there are a wealth of differences. Looking at wolfgang petersons blockbuster troy 2004, the lecture. Part three troy the iliad agamemnon did not do this in the book agamemnon brought the kings together for war the greeks won the war, and the trojan horse let them win. Well learn about the characters in each version and how the. There are a few main differences between hector in the iliad and in the movie troy. Both the film and the poem have the same overall plots, such as the siege of troy by the greeks, the feud between the. In the movie troy, the characters such as achilles, agamemnon are presented in the same way as they are presented in the epic.
Differences between troy movie and the iliad essay example. Comparison of the movie troy and the iliad brandnew. He was commonly referred to as a leader of the trojans and their allies in the defense of troy, killing 31 greek fighters in all. The most powerful warrior in the the iliad and in troy. The reason for these differences between the iliad and the film troy are nearly 100% economic as when looking at each individual example of the differences all of them are either due to lowering expensescomplexity of making the film troy i. The movies closing titles state that the film was inspired by the iliad of homer, but the end of the film is based loosely on book 2 of the aeneid of virgil. Oct 16, 2012 some major differences between homers iliad and wolfgang petersens film troy, is that there was no mention of the gods being participants in the battle of troy. May 27, 2014 the iliad is set during the ten year siege of troy, also known as ilium by a coalition of greek states and describes the events and battles that unfolded during the fight between achilles the warrior and king agamemnon. Discuss similarities and differences between homers iliad. Oct 14, 2012 the reason for these differences between the iliad and the film troy are nearly 100% economic as when looking at each individual example of the differences all of them are either due to lowering expensescomplexity of making the film troy i. Difference of troy movie and iliad freebooksummary. However, in the movie troy the gods are barely even mentioned, and are only mentioned when referred to when signs are received. How does the film about troy in greek mythology differ.
What are the differences and similarities between achilles. Oct 14, 2012 a ancient greek vase depicting ajax preparing to commit suicide the reason for these differences between the iliad and the film troy are nearly 100% economic as when looking at each individual example of the differences all of them are either due to lowering expensescomplexity of making the film troy i. The are many similarities and many difference, in the iliad by homer and the movie troy, for achilles character. The wooden horse and the sack of troy do not appear in the iliad which ends shortly after the funeral of hector. Although, there are many differences that i found between these two. James holoka, professor foreign languages and history at eastern michigan university, who notes that despite this list he did enjoy the movie. In the movie briseis comes from lyrnessus, and is captured by the aecheans before the siege of troy.
Hector is known for his courage but also his noble and courtly nature. Homers iliad, the earliest greek poem, narrates the archetypal war between europeans and asiatics divided by the hellespont. Difference between iliad and odyssey compare the difference. Grace sunny kang hist 151 october 10, 2017 comparison between the epic poem the iliad and the film troy the modernday film troy that was released in 2004 was directed by wolfgang petersen, it was influenced by the epic poem, called the iliad which was written by the poet homer. The greek gods play a central role in all the events as they are depicted in the iliad. What are some of the differences between the events in this movie and in the iliad.
Within the iliad, the gods take sides within the trojan war and are seen fighting amongst the common soldiers. One of the most noticeable differences between the book and the movie is the absence of the gods. Screen adaptations of homers the iliad tend to focus on either the trojan war or the story of helen of troy. Comparing troy with the iliad asian university for. Some events the film where taken straight from the iliad, and is at times the two stories are very similar to one another.
1147 545 262 762 983 600 1349 1158 147 735 499 648 65 517 1157 1278 572 20 961 631 886 547 372 858 516 360 161 870 261 1197 1091 1117 44 987 257 674 1266 1296 425 3 1456